Huang & Huang News | Five Cases Handled by Huang & Huang Co. Law Firm Selected as Typical Cases in Guangdong High People’s Court’s White Paper on the Application of International Treaties and International Practices in Foreign-Related Commercial a
21.10.2026 |NEWS&ARTICLES
Recently, Guangdong High People’s Court released the nation’s first White Paper on the Application of International Treaties and International Practices in Foreign-Related Commercial and Maritime Adjudication, simultaneously publishing ten typical cases, along with various model cases illustrating the courts’ adjudication standards in different circumstances and across different fields. The White Paper systematically reviews the treaty-application practice of the province’s courts over the past decade, and sends a clear signal: the adjudication of cross-border commercial and shipping disputes increasingly relies on an accurate understanding and coordinated application of international conventions and international practices.
From 2016 to 2025, the Guangdong courts concluded 4,574 cases involving the application of international treaties and international practices, covering some 30 categories including international sales of goods, air transport, freight forwarding, ship collision, multimodal transport, salvage at sea, general average, and marine insurance. Three cases handled by us, Huang & Huang Co. Law Firm, were selected among the ten typical cases, and two other cases represented by us were cited in the rules section of the White Paper. Spanning ship collision, salvage at sea and marine insurance, together with an aviation subrogation dispute, these cases exemplify our firm’s consistent approach to cross-border dispute resolution: determine the applicable law first, then address substantive liability.
For companies expanding overseas, domestic-law thinking cannot simply be transplanted into foreign-related litigation. What our lawyers have long specialized in is precisely putting international rules such as the COLREGs 1972, the 1989 Salvage Convention, the Montreal Convention, the New York Convention and the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods into practice — in apportioning liability, allocating salvage, limiting insurance liability and mitigating losses through settlement.

Selected Case 1 | Dispute over Damages for Ship Collision between Guang Company and Tan Company
Clients: Vietnamese Tan Company and its hull insurer and P&Iclub
[Case Summary]
MT “Da” owned by Guang Company collided with MV “T” owned by Vietnamese Tan Company in the Pearl River waters. The Nansha MSA determined that Da’s failure to keep a proper lookout and its improper crossing measures were the primary cause, while T’s failure to use a safe speed was the secondary cause. Guang Company claimed 70% liability against T’s ship interests.
[Holding]
China and Vietnam are both Contracting States to the Convention on the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea, 1972 (the “Convention”). The parties to the litigation chose to apply the Convention, which was applied in conjunction with the Provisions on Safe Navigation of Ships within the Jurisdiction of the Guangdong Maritime Safety Administration pursuant to Article 1(2) of the Convention. Guangzhou Maritime Court ruled that Guang Company should bear 65% of the loss and Tan Company 35%.
[Significance]
This case demonstrates how international treaties and special domestic navigation rules can be applied in a coordinated manner, and was selected by the Supreme People’s Court in the “2023 Typical Cases on the Application of International Treaties and International Practices in Foreign-related Civil and Commercial Cases”.
Huang & Huang’s Note: The collision case between “T” and “Da” was also selected into the “Top 10 Typical Maritime Cases of the Year 2023” by Guangzhou Maritime Court. Besides, the case was awarded as an “Exemplary Case” by LegalOne and an “Annual Achievement Award 2023” by Guangzhou Lawyers Association. After liability was determined in litigation, our lawyers leveraged the liability finding to facilitate a package settlement between the two vessels, reducing the clients’ overall exposure by 70%. A ship collision sets off a chain of technical, legal and economic issues. Maritime lawyers must not only know the law and litigate skillfully, but also understand the technology and the seamanship involved — and, above all, apply the collision regulations and the navigation rules of the waters where the accident occurred accurately, laying a solid foundation for the ensuing claims negotiations.

Selected Case 2 | Insurance Liability Claim Brought by the Owners of MV “Ou”, a Chinese-Flagged Fish Carrier Against Their Insurer
Clients: An insurance company and its Beijing branch
[Case Summary]
The vessel “Ou” ran onto a reef in the Marshall Islands. After the shipowner engaged a pollution-response company to pump out the oil for pollution prevention, it claimed against the bunker pollution liability insurer. The insurer contended that the oil pumping operation served multiple purposes — salvage, wreck removal and pollution cleanup — and that the costs should therefore be apportioned among the several insurance covers.
[Holding]
The court held that the purpose of purpose of the oil pumping was to prevent marine pollution; it did not constitute a “salvage operation” under the International Convention on Salvage, 1989, nor did it fall within the scope of the Nairobi International Convention on the Removal of Wrecks, 2007. The costs therefore fell within the coverage of the bunker pollution liability insurance. The court of first instance supported the claim for payment, and Guangdong High People’s Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the original judgment.
[Significance]
This single case spans three international maritime conventions, bringing claims for pollution-prevention costs in ocean fisheries back onto the track of characterization under the conventions, and safeguarding both the enterprise’s insurance entitlements and its obligations under marine ecological commitments.
Huang & Huang’s Note: In maritime casualties, a single operation often serves multiple purposes — salvage, pollution response, wreck removal — and this case is a case in point. Under which insurance should the oil-discharge costs be claimed? Is there double insurance among the hull, pollution liability and P&I covers? The liabilities are closely interlocking. In parallel proceedings in two countries, how could the bunker insurer, relying on the 2001 Bunkers Convention and the insurance contract, confine the entire insurance liability within a single limitation amount and a single insurance limit? Clarifying insurance liability and resolving disputes — this is precisely where the value of specialist maritime lawyers lies.
Clients: An insurance company and its Beijing branch
[Case Summary]
The vessel “Ou” ran onto a reef in the Marshall Islands. After the shipowner engaged a pollution-response company to pump out the oil for pollution prevention, it claimed against the bunker pollution liability insurer. The insurer contended that the oil pumping operation served multiple purposes — salvage, wreck removal and pollution cleanup — and that the costs should therefore be apportioned among the several insurance covers.
[Holding]
The court held that the purpose of purpose of the oil pumping was to prevent marine pollution; it did not constitute a “salvage operation” under the International Convention on Salvage, 1989, nor did it fall within the scope of the Nairobi International Convention on the Removal of Wrecks, 2007. The costs therefore fell within the coverage of the bunker pollution liability insurance. The court of first instance supported the claim for payment, and Guangdong High People’s Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the original judgment.
[Significance]
This single case spans three international maritime conventions, bringing claims for pollution-prevention costs in ocean fisheries back onto the track of characterization under the conventions, and safeguarding both the enterprise’s insurance entitlements and its obligations under marine ecological commitments.
Huang & Huang’s Note: In maritime casualties, a single operation often serves multiple purposes — salvage, pollution response, wreck removal — and this case is a case in point. Under which insurance should the oil-discharge costs be claimed? Is there double insurance among the hull, pollution liability and P&I covers? The liabilities are closely interlocking. In parallel proceedings in two countries, how could the bunker insurer, relying on the 2001 Bunkers Convention and the insurance contract, confine the entire insurance liability within a single limitation amount and a single insurance limit? Clarifying insurance liability and resolving disputes — this is precisely where the value of specialist maritime lawyers lies.

Selected Case 3 | Salvage Contract Dispute between a Salvage Bureau, a Foreign-Transport Company and Others
Clients: An insurance company and its insured, Nanjing SLD Company
[Case Summary]
A salvage bureau engaged the vessel “Yuan” to carry wind-power equipment from Zhongshan, China to Vietnam; the vessel went aground in Vietnamese waters en route. After assisting with the refloating, the salvage bureau claimed salvage remuneration against the shipowner, the bareboat charterer and the carrier of the goods. The parties differed sharply on whether the operation constituted salvage at sea and who should pay for it.
[Holding]
The court found that the operation constituted “no cure — no pay” salvage and applied the International Convention on Salvage, 1989 as the primary source of law. Company A and Company B were held liable in proportion to the value of the vessel and property salved; the Foreign-transport Company was ordered to pay remuneration in proportion to the voyage freight out of the total value salved. After the first-instance judgment, all parties accepted it without appeal.
[Significance]
The case accurately defines the salvor’s right to remuneration under the said Convention and the boundaries of liability among the various interested parties, providing a judicial yardstick for salvage-cost apportionment disputes arising as offshore wind power — a new quality productive force — goes global.
Huang & Huang’s Note: When heavy-lift wind-power equipment transportation meets salvage at sea, who should bear the costs, and how much? This case involves the interests of multiple parties in an offshore engineering project — shipowner, cargo interests and shippers. The difficulty lay in accurately distinguishing ship interests, cargo interests and freight interests under the 1989 Salvage Convention, and in clarifying the allocation of salvage costs. Commissioned by the insurer, our team assisted in handling the case and provided litigation-strategy support for the insured, successfully “squeezing the water out” of the claim — striking out a large volume of unreasonable items and substantially reducing the amount claimed.

Case Cited in the White Paper | Dispute over Liability for Marine Property Damage between Mu Company, Zhong Company and Others
Clients: The shipper, a Hebei chemical company (a joint-stock company)
[Case Summary]
The Singapore-flagged vessel “Ma” suffered a major fire in waters off Oman; cargo of SDID (sodium dichloroisocyanurate dihydrate) stowed in Hold No. 3 was suspected to be the source of the fire. The vessel was severely damaged and five crew members lost their lives. The shipowner, Mu Company, alleged that the 23 shippers/producers had been negligent in declaration, packaging, segregation within containers and stowage, such as to constitute a jointly dangerous activity, and claimed joint and several damages of USD109 million. Zhong Company was one of the 23 defendants.
[Holding]
The court systematically set out the boundaries of application of the International Maritime Dangerous Goods (IMDG) Code, and found that each defendant had completed the dangerous-goods declaration in accordance with the IMDG Code then in force, with no violation; and that the existing evidence could not prove any fault on the defendants’ part in respect of the damage. All of Mu Company’s claims were dismissed. All parties accepted the judgment without appeal.
[Significance]
This was the exceptionally serious maritime casualty of the year as recognized by Singapore’s transport authorities, and drew close attention from the international shipping community. The judgment clarified the boundaries of lawful declaration by shippers of hazardous chemicals and drew a clear line between lawful consignment and tortious fault; the hearing was webcast in its entirety, with more than 12,000 viewings online, demonstrating the authority of China’s maritime judiciary in adjudicating international dangerous-goods transport disputes and enhancing the international voice and influence of Chinese justice.
Huang & Huang’s Note: This case is a benchmark model for cross-border dangerous-goods transport claims. The massive claim of USD109 million was dismissed in its entirety; the central battleground was not “how the fire started”, but where the shipper’s obligations under the IMDG Code actually end. The case offers a highly instructive risk-control reference for enterprises exporting new-energy hazardous chemicals and water-treatment raw materials: whether the cargo declaration complies with the rules and whether the relevant obligations are duly discharged directly determine the liability borne after a casualty.
Clients: The shipper, a Hebei chemical company (a joint-stock company)
[Case Summary]
The Singapore-flagged vessel “Ma” suffered a major fire in waters off Oman; cargo of SDID (sodium dichloroisocyanurate dihydrate) stowed in Hold No. 3 was suspected to be the source of the fire. The vessel was severely damaged and five crew members lost their lives. The shipowner, Mu Company, alleged that the 23 shippers/producers had been negligent in declaration, packaging, segregation within containers and stowage, such as to constitute a jointly dangerous activity, and claimed joint and several damages of USD109 million. Zhong Company was one of the 23 defendants.
[Holding]
The court systematically set out the boundaries of application of the International Maritime Dangerous Goods (IMDG) Code, and found that each defendant had completed the dangerous-goods declaration in accordance with the IMDG Code then in force, with no violation; and that the existing evidence could not prove any fault on the defendants’ part in respect of the damage. All of Mu Company’s claims were dismissed. All parties accepted the judgment without appeal.
[Significance]
This was the exceptionally serious maritime casualty of the year as recognized by Singapore’s transport authorities, and drew close attention from the international shipping community. The judgment clarified the boundaries of lawful declaration by shippers of hazardous chemicals and drew a clear line between lawful consignment and tortious fault; the hearing was webcast in its entirety, with more than 12,000 viewings online, demonstrating the authority of China’s maritime judiciary in adjudicating international dangerous-goods transport disputes and enhancing the international voice and influence of Chinese justice.
Huang & Huang’s Note: This case is a benchmark model for cross-border dangerous-goods transport claims. The massive claim of USD109 million was dismissed in its entirety; the central battleground was not “how the fire started”, but where the shipper’s obligations under the IMDG Code actually end. The case offers a highly instructive risk-control reference for enterprises exporting new-energy hazardous chemicals and water-treatment raw materials: whether the cargo declaration complies with the rules and whether the relevant obligations are duly discharged directly determine the liability borne after a casualty.

Case Cited in the White Paper | Subrogation Claim between P Company’s Guangzhou Branch, Zhong Company and Third Party Mo Company
Client: Zhong Company (a Macao enterprise)
Rule Insight: The place of business is not what triggers the application of the Montreal Convention.
The cargo was damaged during air carriage from the United States to Hong Kong. The court made clear that, even though all parties’ places of business are within China, the Montreal Convention applies whenever the carriage constitutes "international carriage" under Article 1 of the Convention; whether the Convention applies to Macao does not affect the conclusion in this case.
[Practical Outcome]
Our lawyer team closely pursued the two-layer defense of “international carriage characterization + Convention liability limits”, and the court ultimately adjudicated in accordance with the limitation of liability under the Montreal Convention, with Zhong Company actually paying a little over RMB4,000 — a near-total reduction of the exposure for our Client.
When interpreting the White Paper, a deputy to the National People’s Congress observed: “For enterprises going global, understanding the treaties and observing the rules is the precondition; the governing law, arbitration clause and limitation of liability in the contract must be spelled out clearly.” The underlying logic of our foreign-related maritime practice has never been merely “fighting a lawsuit to the end”, but using international treaties and international practices to safeguard clients throughout — the contract beforehand, the claims handling in the course of the casualty, and the litigation or settlement afterwards. Only those who command the international rules can take on the real challenges of shipping under the “Belt and Road” initiative and in the Greater Bay Area.
Concluding Remarks: Foreign-related commercial and maritime adjudication not only resolves specific disputes, but also carries the important mission of showcasing the nation’s rule-of-law image and participating in the building of the global governance system. While the Guangdong courts have long been strengthening the building of their foreign-related adjudication ranks and enhancing their ability to apply international rules, our lawyers have been steadily accumulating experience through the numerous foreign-related and cross-border disputes they handle. With the selection of multiple Huang & Huang cases as typical cases by the Guangdong High People’s Court serving as a springboard, we will continue to build on our strengths in maritime and admiralty, aviation, multimodal transport, marine insurance, new-energy sectors going global and other fields, further enhance our professional service capabilities, and vigorously safeguard clients’ rights and interests through high-quality, efficient and practical foreign-related legal services.
Further reading (the original text of the Guangdong High People’s Court White Paper):
https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/BiBWtibVdSQzY4DMRxOK6w
Client: Zhong Company (a Macao enterprise)
Rule Insight: The place of business is not what triggers the application of the Montreal Convention.
The cargo was damaged during air carriage from the United States to Hong Kong. The court made clear that, even though all parties’ places of business are within China, the Montreal Convention applies whenever the carriage constitutes "international carriage" under Article 1 of the Convention; whether the Convention applies to Macao does not affect the conclusion in this case.
[Practical Outcome]
Our lawyer team closely pursued the two-layer defense of “international carriage characterization + Convention liability limits”, and the court ultimately adjudicated in accordance with the limitation of liability under the Montreal Convention, with Zhong Company actually paying a little over RMB4,000 — a near-total reduction of the exposure for our Client.
When interpreting the White Paper, a deputy to the National People’s Congress observed: “For enterprises going global, understanding the treaties and observing the rules is the precondition; the governing law, arbitration clause and limitation of liability in the contract must be spelled out clearly.” The underlying logic of our foreign-related maritime practice has never been merely “fighting a lawsuit to the end”, but using international treaties and international practices to safeguard clients throughout — the contract beforehand, the claims handling in the course of the casualty, and the litigation or settlement afterwards. Only those who command the international rules can take on the real challenges of shipping under the “Belt and Road” initiative and in the Greater Bay Area.
Concluding Remarks: Foreign-related commercial and maritime adjudication not only resolves specific disputes, but also carries the important mission of showcasing the nation’s rule-of-law image and participating in the building of the global governance system. While the Guangdong courts have long been strengthening the building of their foreign-related adjudication ranks and enhancing their ability to apply international rules, our lawyers have been steadily accumulating experience through the numerous foreign-related and cross-border disputes they handle. With the selection of multiple Huang & Huang cases as typical cases by the Guangdong High People’s Court serving as a springboard, we will continue to build on our strengths in maritime and admiralty, aviation, multimodal transport, marine insurance, new-energy sectors going global and other fields, further enhance our professional service capabilities, and vigorously safeguard clients’ rights and interests through high-quality, efficient and practical foreign-related legal services.
Further reading (the original text of the Guangdong High People’s Court White Paper):
https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/BiBWtibVdSQzY4DMRxOK6w